Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephen Nass's avatar

With all that nudity this does NOT sound like a film catholics should watch.

Expand full comment
Ben Kercheval's avatar

Thanks for this review - I also found it to be a refreshing and poignant, if imperfect, film. I am curious what the author (or other readers), as Catholics, thought of the decision to have the mother be killed (and incinerated!) by the doctor after we learn she has advanced cancer. Perhaps I'm unduly projecting my political concerns, but in light of the advances assisted suicide and euthanasia legislation has been making in Western nations as of late (including in Britain), this choice seemed sadly apropos of our cultural moment. I think this is especially the case given that the doctor and his "memento mori" philosophy in the film are pointedly depicted as providing a kind of humane freedom and compassion in a world otherwise closed to those possibilities. This, of course, aligns well with the real world arguments put forward in support of physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia.

Beyond this narrative choice itself, I was also struck by the abruptness with which it was presented, with no time to deliberate, prepare, or even properly say goodbye, as if it was *obviously* the best way to approach the problem of the mother's suffering and any resistance the boy may have mounted needed to be preemptively nipped in the bud (for his own good, no doubt).

Anyways, I don't mean this to take too much away from the film's virtues, but it did strike me as odd and unfortunately took me out of the narrative flow. Although I do agree the ending was also strange.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts